Eat and drink in Shelter Island

Every place we know of

From public listings. We have not confirmed these yet, so check with the business before you go.

Restaurants

• 18 BayAmerican restaurant
• Chequit InnAmerican restaurant
• Commander Cody's Fish ShoppeSeafood restaurant
• Kyle'sRestaurant
• Maria's KitchenMexican restaurant
• Opties & DinghiesDumpling restaurant
• Opties & DinghiesSeafood restaurant
• Opties and DinghiesRestaurant
• Pridwin HotelSeafood restaurant
• Ram's Head InnAmerican restaurant
• Red MapleAmerican restaurant
• SALT Waterfront Bar & GrillSeafood restaurant
• Shelter Island SeafoodSeafood restaurant
• Shelter Island SlicePizza restaurant
• The Boathouse Shelter IslandSeafood restaurant
• The Eccentric BagelBagel shop
• The IslanderComfort food restaurant

Bars and wine

• Jamesport Vineyard Tasting RoomWinery
• Shelter Island Craft BreweryBrewery
• Shipwreck Boat BarBar

Coffee and cafes

• Marie Eiffel MarketCafe
• Vine Street CaféCafe

Bakeries and sweets

• Tuck ShopIce cream parlor
• Whale's TaleIce cream parlor