Long Island collectors have a new counter to bring their binders to. Replay Sports Cards is open at 2156 Bellmore Avenue in Bellmore, the first New York location for the sports card shop chain, which also has stores in Florida, North Carolina, Colorado, Indiana, Kansas and Tennessee.
Who is behind it
The Bellmore shop is run by Rob Ansalone, a Merrick native and lifelong sports fan. According to the company, Ansalone came to cards after a career in insurance and a stint owning a gym franchise, and he set out to build a shop where Long Island fans and families can meet over the hobby.
What the shop does
Replay's model is a full-service card shop: collectors can buy, sell, trade and grade sports cards there. Grading is the step where a card is authenticated, scored on condition and sealed in a hard case. The shop also carries sealed boxes and graded cards, called slabs.
Beyond the counter, Replay runs live box breaks and auctions on Whatnot, where it streams seven days a week, and sells a selection of boxes and slabs online with shipping across North America. Its team also buys and sells at major card shows and sporting events around the country.
Birthdays and private events
The Bellmore store books private events for birthdays, graduations and other gatherings, with packages that give a group the shop to themselves for trading, browsing and activities planned around the hobby. Requests go through a form on the Bellmore page, and the shop replies with availability and pricing.
Rewards
Replay runs a rewards list, Replay Rewards, that sends news of product drops and enters members in giveaways of cards, boxes and shop gear. Sign-up is on the company's site.
Hours and how to reach the shop
Replay Sports Cards Bellmore is open every day from 11 a.m. to 6 p.m. at 2156 Bellmore Avenue, Bellmore. Call 516-242-9681, or follow the store on Instagram at @replaybellmore for new arrivals and events.

Loading comments…