Overtime Arena is opening in December 2026 at 635 Middle Country Road in Selden, with multi-sport simulator bays carrying more than thirty sports and games, a Batbox batting cage, racing simulators, a gaming lounge, and a full bar and kitchen, all under one roof. The arena's motto is on its sign: "Play. Compete. Unwind."

One bay, more than thirty sports

Every simulator bay runs HD SportSuite, the multi-sport platform from the makers of HD Golf, so the same screen that hosts a round of golf can host a penalty shootout, a hockey shootout and a field goal contest a minute later, with no moving to another bay. Settings adjust for different ages and athletic abilities, so a kids party and a league night use the same bay. The batting cage is Batbox, whose leaderboard reaches every Batbox in the world.

Four friends in batting helmets posing with a bat and a baseball inside a batting cage

What there is to play

  • The Batbox batting cage: real baseballs from a smart pitching system, every swing read by sensors, and full 3- and 9-inning games, a home run challenge, a batting challenge and a pitching challenge. Bats and balls are provided.
  • Golf simulators: championship courses on HD Golf, a driving range with launch, spin and carry data on every swing, plus closest-to-the-pin and long drive contests.
  • Hockey: shootouts, target practice and hardest-shot contests against a reactive virtual goalie.
  • Football: field goal kicking, passing accuracy and a quarterback challenge.
  • Soccer: penalty kicks, finishing drills, team battles and footgolf.
  • Basketball: shootouts, around the world and head-to-head games.
  • More games: bowling, dodgeball, lacrosse, handball, cornhole, bocce, horseshoes, croquet, carnival games, archery and clay shooting, game hunts, and arcade titles like Alien Assault and Zombie Survival.
  • Racing simulators and esports and gaming: racing seats with a wheel and pedals, and console and PC stations for open play, private sessions and tournaments.
A golfer mid-swing in an indoor golf simulator bay

Indoor golf all winter in Suffolk

For golfers, the arena's HD Golf bays put championship courses built from real-world data and a driving range with shot data indoors, rain or shine, and a winter golf league is planned for the first season. Golfers are welcome to bring their own clubs, though clubs are provided.

A full bar and kitchen

Overtime Arena is a full restaurant as well as a bar, with food served at a table or right to your bay, and a full bar pouring draft beer, signature cocktails, wine and zero-proof options. Every big game is on wall-to-wall screens, with watch parties on game days.

Parties, team events and buyouts

Overtime Arena hosts birthday parties for kids, teens and grown-ups, corporate events from team building to client nights and holiday parties, end-of-season team celebrations, and private buyouts of the whole arena. Bookings open ahead of the opening: send a request through the Plan an Event page and the events team will reach out with dates and packages.

Leagues and tournaments

Leagues and tournaments in golf, racing and esports are planned, and anyone on the opening list hears first when registration opens.

Close to home in central Suffolk

Selden is in the Town of Brookhaven, a short drive from Centereach, Coram, Lake Grove, Farmingville, Port Jefferson Station, Stony Brook, Ronkonkoma, Medford, Patchogue and Smithtown. No experience is needed: every simulator has modes for first-timers, and the staff will have you set up and playing in a couple of minutes.

Plan a visit

Overtime Arena is at 635 Middle Country Road, Suite 101, in Selden, on Route 25, opening December 2026. Join the opening list to hear first when the date and hours are announced, see how to get there, read the FAQ, or start at theovertimearena.com. Follow along on Instagram, Facebook and LinkedIn.