Overtime Arena is a sports simulator arena with a full bar and restaurant at 635 Middle Country Road in Selden, in the Town of Brookhaven on Long Island, scheduled to open in December 2026. Its site describes it as a home for leagues and tournaments as well as casual play, with HD SportSuite multi-sport bays, a Batbox batting cage, racing rigs and a gaming lounge under one roof.

Planned Leagues at Overtime Arena in Selden

The arena's leagues and tournaments page lists five planned formats, with registration opening when the arena opens. Schedules have not been published, and the site invites players to join its opening list to hear first. Players can register solo, with a partner or as a whole team, depending on the league.

Home Run Derby Nights in the Batbox Batting Cage

Home Run Derby Nights is a weekly derby in the Batbox batting cage. Each player gets a set number of swings in the cage's home run challenge, the sensors score every swing and an arena board tracks the season. The derby is planned with a youth division and an open division on the same nights, since difficulty in the cage adjusts to each player. The season final sends the winner's run onto the leaderboard Batbox shares across its locations worldwide.

Winter Golf League on Long Island

The Winter Golf League pairs teams of two for a weekly round on famous courses in the arena's HD Golf simulator bays, with handicaps so every level can compete, season standings and a playoff night. The arena's winter golf guide covers how the bays read ball speed, spin and clubface angle.

Racing Series, Esports Nights and the Sports Sim Challenge

A Racing Series on the racing simulators is planned with qualifying, races, a points table and a podium at the finale. Esports Nights in the esports and gaming lounge run weekly brackets in sports, fighting and shooter titles, open to solo players and squads. The Sports Sim Challenge rotates players through hockey, football, soccer, basketball and bowling in the multi-sport bays, with the best all-around athlete taking the belt.

Hosted Tournaments and Existing Leagues in Suffolk County

Company tournaments, charity events and club nights can be hosted at the arena. Its staff runs brackets and scoring, puts live leaderboards on the big screens, supplies food and drink packages for players and spectators, and arranges prizes and trophies on request. Existing golf, racing and gaming leagues are welcome, and requests go through the Plan an Event form.

Overtime Arena at a Glance

  • What it is: a sports simulator arena with a full bar and restaurant
  • Address: 635 Middle Country Road, Suite 101, Selden, NY 11784, on Route 25 in Suffolk County
  • Opening: December 2026, with hours to be announced
  • Planned leagues: Home Run Derby Nights, Winter Golf League, Racing Series, Esports Nights, Sports Sim Challenge
  • Technology: HD SportSuite bays and a Batbox batting cage, explained on the tech page
  • Parking: free, in the lot at the building
  • Website: theovertimearena.com

Frequently Asked Questions About Overtime Arena

Does Overtime Arena have leagues?

Yes. Golf, racing, esports and Home Run Derby leagues are planned, with registration opening alongside the arena in December 2026.

Where is Overtime Arena?

At 635 Middle Country Road, Suite 101, in Selden, NY, on Route 25 just east of Patchogue-Mount Sinai Road, according to the visit page.

Do players need their own equipment?

No. Clubs, sticks and balls are provided, and golfers are welcome to bring their own clubs, the arena's FAQ says.