Long Island has plenty of restaurants that put a French word on the menu. It has very few French restaurants, in the full sense: a room that runs the classical canon end to end, sends a cart to your table, and keeps a cellar deep enough to matter. We think the best one on the Island is sitting in a hundred-year-old storefront in Oyster Bay, and we think it is worth the drive from wherever you are reading this.
L'Étoile occupies a corner of the historic Snouder's Building at 108 South Street, in the middle of the village. It is dinner only, six nights a week. There is no lunch and there is no brunch. The doors open at five Tuesday through Saturday and at four on Sunday, the kitchen runs until ten, and Monday the lights are off. That narrow format is the first thing to understand about the place: it does one service, and it builds the entire evening around it.
The case for the drive
Calling something the best of anything on Long Island is an invitation to argue, so here is the argument, and every piece of it is checkable.
Start with the cellar, because it is the part that is genuinely hard to match. L'Étoile carries all five of the 1855 Bordeaux First Growths, and it carries Domaine de la Romanée Conti. There are steakhouses in Manhattan with a shallower Bordeaux page. More on that below, because it deserves its own section.
Then the kitchen, which does not cherry-pick the canon. Escargots, soupe à l'oignon, frisée aux lardons, moules frites in four different sauces, duck magret, lobster thermidor, a proper plateau de fruits de mer and three tartares. That is a French menu, not a French accent on an American one.
Then the service, which is the detail most places on the Island have quietly given up. The steak tartare is mixed at your table off a wooden cart. Desserts are finished at the table. That is the old guéridon tradition, it costs a restaurant real labor to keep, and almost nobody out here still does it.
Then the beef, which is aged a few doors away by a butcher shop in the same family. And then the room itself, which is small, marble-topped and candlelit, and seats a village storefront rather than a banquet hall.
Put those together and you have a French dining room that is complete in a way that is rare anywhere in Nassau or Suffolk. Hence the drive.
A hundred years on South Street
The restaurant takes a quiet corner of the Snouder's Building rather than the whole of it, in a storefront the house says has been part of the village's main street for over a century. The restaurant makes a point of that in its own telling, calling the room understated and elegant and designed for a more intimate kind of dining. In practice it means marble tables, warm light, and a first floor that fills without ever quite feeling loud.
The name is the tell about the family, too. L'Étoile is French for the star. A few blocks up the same street, Stellina Ristorante is Italian for the little star. That is not a coincidence, and we will come back to it.
The tartare arrives on a cart
The menu opens with a section called Froid, and the tartares are the argument. There are three of them, steak at $32, tuna at $30 and salmon at $30, and a Dégustation de Tartares at $60 that puts all three on one plate, with caviar available as a $30 supplement. The steak version is built the classical way, with capers, shallots, cornichons, Dijon, Worcestershire and a cured egg yolk, and it is finished at the table off a wooden cart rather than assembled in the kitchen and carried out. The restaurant's own photography leads with it, which tells you how much the house thinks it matters.
The rest of the cold list reads like a French bistro that has decided not to cut corners: foie gras au torchon with fig jam and summer truffles at $28, a cheese and charcuterie board at $36, whipped goat cheese with hot honey and walnuts, and a tomato stuffed with shrimp and langoustine under a pink cocktail sauce.
Then the hot starters, which is where the classics live. Escargots de Bourgogne in garlic butter at $25. Soupe à l'Oignon at $20. Baked brie with honey, pecans and thyme. Endives au gratin under béchamel, ham and Gruyère. The one to know is the Macaroni au Homard et Crabe, the house's signature pasta, mornay sauce with lobster and crab under a bread crumb crust, at $34.
Oysters in Oyster Bay, and a tower for the table
A French room in a town called Oyster Bay has an obvious obligation and L'Étoile meets it. Oysters of the day come by the six at $19, the dozen at $38 or eighteen at $57, and the full Tour de Fruits de Mer, built for two to four people, is $115. The tray is assembled to the table in one, two or three tiers, with oysters, langoustines, shrimp and chilled lobster on crushed ice, and caviar service with blini and crème fraîche available at market price. The restaurant asks that you mention caviar when you book so it is chilled and waiting, though the tower itself needs no notice.
Moules four ways, and steak aged down the street
Moules frites is a fixed $36 and comes four ways: marinière in white wine, leek and cream, provençale in tomato, pepper and red wine, a curry and cream version, and a mustard cream. Each one arrives with fries. It is the least expensive way to eat properly here and probably the most French thing on the menu.
The steak section is where the local detail is genuinely good. Every steak is USDA Prime Omaha beef, and the aging is done by The Bay Butcher at 96 South Street, which is to say by a butcher shop in the same family, a few doors down the same street. Filet mignon runs $68, dry-aged sirloin $75, dry-aged ribeye and T-bone $95 each, and a dry-aged porterhouse for two is $165. All of them come with frites and a choice of six sauces: bordelaise, au poivre, béarnaise, mushroom, foie gras butter or garlic butter. There is also a burger, the Burger L'Étoile, at $29, with comté, cornichon, crispy shallot and bacon on brioche.
Elsewhere on the mains: lobster thermidor at $68, Chilean sea bass with butternut velouté and lump crab at $65, a duck magret with orange and pink peppercorn at $49, and a pan-seared wild salmon in dill mustard cream at $38. Sides are $13 to $15 and include a potato purée made the Joël Robuchon way, which is to say with a quantity of butter nobody at the table needs to know about.
The list is the real surprise
Most village restaurants keep a wine list. L'Étoile keeps a cellar, roughly two hundred bottles, organized region by region rather than by grape: Champagne, then Beaujolais, Alsace, the Languedoc, Chablis and the rest of Burgundy, the Loire from Vouvray to Sancerre, Provence, the Rhône, even a page from the Jura, before it crosses to Italy and California.
Read far enough and the list stops behaving like a restaurant list. All five of the 1855 Bordeaux First Growths are on it: Château Margaux, Château Latour, Château Lafite Rothschild, Château Haut-Brion and Château Mouton Rothschild. Margaux alone is offered in six vintages going back to 1982, with the 1982 listed at $3,600 and more recent vintages from around $1,400. Latour runs back to 1982 as well. Burgundy answers with two bottlings from Domaine de la Romanée Conti, an Échezeaux Grand Cru at $2,950 and a Romanée-Saint-Vivant Grand Cru at $5,000.
None of which is the point for most evenings. Wines by the glass start at $8 on the happy hour list and the everyday pages are full of bottles built to sit next to moules and a steak. But a cellar with that ceiling, in a room this size, in a hamlet this size, is worth knowing about, and it explains the corkage policy: you are welcome to bring your own bottle, and the fee is $75.
Le Bar, before the room fills
The bar keeps a short cocktail list rather than a clever one, mostly $18 to $22, and the names do the work: an L'Étoile 75 with gin, lemon, grapefruit bitters and crémant, a Left-Bank Martini with elderflower and sauvignon blanc, a Side-Car d'Été with strawberry shrub, and a mezcal and Aperol drink called the Slow Burn. Beer runs French and Belgian, Kronenbourg and Chouffe, with non-alcoholic options on the same list.
There is a happy hour, and the useful thing about it is that you can order it anywhere in the restaurant rather than only at the bar. Six plates at $15 and $18, including grilled oysters, tuna tartare, French onion soup and a mac and cheese skillet, wines by the glass at $8 and $9, beer at $5, and a different featured spirit each week. The restaurant does not publish the current times, so call (516) 730-8088 before you plan an early evening around it.
Save room. Desserts are $13 to $17 and several are finished at the table, including a crêpe flambéed with Grand Marnier at $17 and a crème brûlée at $15 that is worth ordering for the sound alone.
Taking the room
Parties of eight and up move into private dining, and there are two ways to do it: a private room on the lower level, or a full buyout of the first floor. The kitchen plans the menu with you rather than handing over a package, the wine is chosen to match, and the house asks for four to six weeks of notice, more for December and spring weekends. There is a food and beverage minimum that varies by night and party size, and the restaurant quotes it up front. Bring a cake if you are celebrating, and tell them when you inquire so the dessert course is built around it.
One family, one street
L'Étoile belongs to Stellina Hospitality, which by now owns a remarkable share of Oyster Bay's dinner hour. Stellina Ristorante is the chef-driven Italian dining room at 76 South Street. The Audrey, at 30 Audrey Avenue, is the all-day kitchen and bar, and we wrote about it earlier this month. The Bay Butcher is the market and butcher shop at 96 South Street. Hoshi, an omakase counter and dining room, is coming to 34 Audrey Avenue. And in Farmingdale, Casa Stellina carries the Italian side of the family into Nassau's other main street, which we covered last summer.
Within that group L'Étoile plays the formal role. It is the one you book for the anniversary, the birthday that ends in a zero, and the dinner where somebody is going to open something old. A gift card bought at any of them, incidentally, spends at all of them.
Getting there from the rest of the North Shore
Oyster Bay is the part of the Gold Coast that most of Long Island drives past rather than into, which is exactly why a restaurant like this can sit in it without a line down the block. From Locust Valley, Bayville, Mill Neck or Glen Cove it is a short run over. From Syosset, Woodbury, Jericho or Muttontown it is a straightforward twenty minutes or so. From Cold Spring Harbor, Huntington and Northport, cross the county line and you are there in about the same. Manhasset, Great Neck and Garden City are a longer drive, and the kind of evening this room is built for is worth it.
There is also a train. The Long Island Rail Road's Oyster Bay branch terminates in the village itself, a short walk from South Street, which makes L'Étoile one of the few genuinely serious dining rooms in Nassau County you can reach without a designated driver. Given the wine list, that is not a small point.
Once you are in the village you are also inside a small cluster of good things. Stellina Ristorante is a few blocks down the same street, The Audrey is around the corner on Audrey Avenue, and Theodore Roosevelt's Sagamore Hill and the harbor are both minutes away. An afternoon and a dinner assemble themselves.
If you go
L'Étoile is at 108 South Street in Oyster Bay, open for dinner from 5 to 10 PM Tuesday through Saturday, from 4 to 10 PM on Sunday, and closed Monday. Reservations are on OpenTable or by phone at (516) 730-8088, parties of eight and above go through private dining, and pickup orders run through the restaurant's own online ordering during kitchen hours. Corkage is $75 per bottle. All prices above are as listed on August 30, 2026, and a menu is a living document, so confirm anything you are counting on at letoileny.com before you build an evening around it. The restaurant draws regularly from Oyster Bay, Locust Valley, Glen Cove, Cold Spring Harbor and Huntington, and on a Saturday night you should book ahead from any of them.
Loading comments…