Potbelly, the Chicago-born chain known for oven-toasted sandwiches, opens its first Long Island shop today, Tuesday, November 17, at 909 Hillside Avenue in New Hyde Park. The shop sits in North Shore Commons, at the corner of Hillside Avenue and Lakeville Road, near the Lake Success Shopping Center and New Hyde Park Plaza.
A Great Neck native behind the counter
The New Hyde Park shop is the first location for Legendary Eats, the franchise group bringing the brand to Long Island. The group's founder first came across Potbelly as a regular customer while attending college in the Midwest, and the group now plans more shops across Nassau, Suffolk and Queens.
Day-to-day operations are led by general manager Eddie Bucher, a lifelong Great Neck resident with more than ten years in Long Island restaurants. In the company's announcement, Bucher said he wants the shop to become a regular stop for people who live and work nearby, and that growing up in Great Neck taught him how much neighborhood businesses matter to the places they serve.
What is on the menu
The shop serves the brand's standard lineup: sandwiches and wraps toasted in the oven, salads, hand-dipped shakes and cookies baked in the shop.
Hours
Regular hours are 10 a.m. to 9 p.m., seven days a week.
A grand opening party on December 11
The shop is open now, but the formal celebration comes later. On Friday, December 11, from 10 a.m. to 1 p.m., the New Hyde Park shop will hold a ribbon cutting along with a prize wheel offering Potbelly giveaways, games and other activities for customers who stop in.
More shops planned
The company describes the Hillside Avenue shop as the brand's debut on Long Island. Legendary Eats has said it plans to open more Potbelly shops in Nassau, Suffolk and Queens, and has not yet named the next locations.
Before you go
Potbelly New Hyde Park is at 909 Hillside Avenue, New Hyde Park, in North Shore Commons at Lakeville Road. Ordering ahead is available through Potbelly's website and app. The grand opening celebration runs 10 a.m. to 1 p.m. on Friday, December 11.

Loading comments…