The Bay Butcher is a butcher shop and seafood market at 96 South Street in Oyster Bay, on the North Shore of Nassau County, Long Island. Alongside USDA Prime beef and a fish counter, the shop now sells ready-to-cook dinner kits that serve four, plus a shelf of prepared meats that go from the case to the pan in minutes.

The shop opened on South Street in May 2026 and belongs to Stellina Hospitality, the group behind several Oyster Bay restaurants. Long Island Wave covered its dry-aged beef program in September; this spotlight is about the weeknight side of the counter.

Ready-to-Cook Dinner Kits at The Bay Butcher

The Bay Butcher introduced four dinner kits this month, each packed so the oven does most of the work and each serving four people. Prices are as listed in November 2026 on the shop's own page.

  • Meatball Dinner, $35: eight ready-to-cook meatballs, a jar of Mutti tomato sauce (marinara or arrabbiata) and a box of La Molisana pasta (penne, linguine or rigatoni).
  • Chicken Cutlet Dinner, $40: two pounds of ready-to-cook chicken cutlets with the same sauce and pasta choices.
  • Meatloaf Dinner, $35: a ready-to-cook meatloaf with sauce and pasta.
  • Roasted Chicken Dinner, $35: an organic La Belle Farm chicken with potatoes and onions, seasoned with olive oil, salt, pepper, garlic powder, onion powder and white wine.

Kits are ordered by phone, not online. Call (516) 273-6733, name the kit, the pasta, the sauce and a pickup time, and the order is packed at the counter.

Prepared Meats from the Oyster Bay Butcher Case

The prepared section of the meat case is built for the same kind of night. The filet mignon skewers are USDA Prime tenderloin cubes alternated with tri-color pepper and red onion, sold plain or in a marinade that rotates weekly, and the shop says two skewers feed one person as a main. The flank steak pinwheels are butterflied flank layered with prosciutto di Parma and aged provolone, rolled, tied and sliced into one-inch rounds that cook in about five minutes.

The case also carries sweet and hot Italian sausage made in the shop, chop meat ground in the shop, house meatballs, marinated pork tenderloin, organic air-chilled chicken cutlets and Kobe hot dogs. For anyone unsure how to cook a cut, the counter publishes short cooking notes for five of them.

Online Ordering and Pickup on South Street

Most of the shop can be ordered ahead through The Bay Butcher's online ordering page: the butcher case, the fish counter, charcuterie, cheese, dairy, produce, caviar and pantry items. Ordering opens with the shop at noon, and orders are wrapped by the same people who work the case. Points from the Stellina Hospitality Rewards program apply to pickup orders too.

The Bay Butcher at a Glance

Frequently Asked Questions About The Bay Butcher

Where is The Bay Butcher?

The shop is at 96 South Street in Oyster Bay, Long Island, three storefronts down from the water. A public lot sits one block away on South Street, with on-street parking nearby.

How much are The Bay Butcher's dinner kits?

As listed in November 2026, the meatball, meatloaf and roasted chicken kits are $35 and the chicken cutlet kit is $40. Every kit serves four.

Can dinner kits be ordered online?

No. The shop takes dinner kit orders by phone at (516) 273-6733; the online ordering page covers the rest of the case.

Does The Bay Butcher take walk-ins?

Yes. The shop's FAQ says walk-ins are always welcome, and the counter will hold an order wrapped and labeled with a name for same-day pickup.