The Ultimate Guide to Long Island's Thrift and Vintage Stores

Long Island is a treasure trove of thrift and vintage stores, offering shoppers a unique and eclectic mix of affordable, pre-loved items. From retro clothing to antique furniture, these stores provide a sustainable shopping experience that allows you to find one-of-a-kind pieces while supporting local businesses. In this ultimate guide, we will introduce you to some of the best thrift and vintage stores on Long Island, so you can embark on an unforgettable shopping adventure.


Key Takeaways

  • Long Island is home to numerous thrift and vintage stores, offering a sustainable shopping experience.

  • These stores offer a wide range of items, including clothing, accessories, furniture, and home decor.

  • This guide will introduce you to some of the best thrift and vintage stores on Long Island.

The Ultimate Guide to Long Island's Thrift and Vintage Stores

My Unique Thrift Westbury

Located in Westbury, My Unique Thrift Westbury is a spacious, well-organized store offering a wide variety of secondhand items, including clothing, shoes, accessories, furniture, and home goods. With new items arriving daily, you're sure to find something special at an affordable price.

Learn More

Paper Doll Vintage Boutique

Paper Doll Vintage Boutique in Sayville is a must-visit for those seeking retro and vintage clothing from the 1920s to the 1990s. This charming store also offers unique accessories, handmade jewelry, and nostalgic home decor items.

Learn More

Hidden Treasures Thrift Shop

Hidden Treasures Thrift Shop in Brentwood offers a wide selection of secondhand items, including clothing, furniture, electronics, and more. Their constantly changing inventory ensures there's always something new to discover.

Learn More

The Huntington Store

The Huntington Store in Huntington is the perfect spot for antique enthusiasts. This store offers a carefully curated selection of antique furniture, home decor, and collectibles, all at reasonable prices.

Learn More

Finder's Keepers

Located in Bay Shore, Finder's Keepers is a hidden gem that offers a mix of thrift and vintage items, including clothing, accessories, furniture, and home decor. The friendly staff and ever-changing inventory make this a go-to destination for treasure hunters.

Learn More

Second Time Around

Second Time Around in East Northport is a consignment shop that specializes in high-quality, gently used clothing and accessories for women, men, and children. With a focus on designer brands and upscale items, this store offers a more refined thrifting experience.

Learn More

Deep End of the Sandbox

Located in Oceanside, Deep End of the Sandbox is a vintage clothing store specializing in rare and hard-to-find pieces. With an expertly curated selection of items from the 1950s to the 1990s, this store is a must-visit for vintage fashion lovers.

Learn More

Antique Attics

Antique Attics in Lake Grove is a treasure trove of antiques, vintage items, and collectibles. From furniture and home decor to toys and memorabilia, this store offers a vast selection of unique items to satisfy any collector's taste.

Learn More


Long Island's thrift and vintage stores offer a wide range of unique and affordable items for shoppers who are passionate about sustainable fashion and home decor. This guide has introduced you to some of the best options in the area, including Antique Attics, Paper Doll Vintage Boutique, The Huntington Store, Hidden Treasures Thrift Shop, Finder's Keepers, Second Time Around, Deep End of the Sandbox, Antique Attics. By exploring these stores, you can enjoy a one-of-a-kind shopping experience that supports local businesses while being environmentally conscious. Happy thrifting!



Previous
Previous

The Best Birdwatching Spots on Long Island: A Feathered Adventure

Next
Next

A Slice of Heaven: A Guide to Long Island's Best Pizza Places