Juicy Journeys: The Top 10 Steakhouses on Long Island: A Carnivore's Delight
Whether it's a classic porterhouse, a tender filet mignon, or a well-marbled ribeye you're craving, Long Island's steakhouses have got you covered. Known for its foodie scene, Long Island offers some of the best spots for beef enthusiasts to satisfy their cravings. In this article, we bring you the definitive guide to the top 10 steakhouses on Long Island.
Key Takeaways
Long Island's steakhouses are diverse and offer a broad range of cuts and styles.
Each steakhouse presents its unique take on the steak, from traditional to innovative.
Steakhouses not only serve great steaks but also a variety of accompanying wines and sides.
The ambiance of these restaurants adds to the overall dining experience.
Vegetarian and seafood options are also available for non-meat eaters.
Prime: An American Kitchen and Bar
Prime is not only a steakhouse but an experience. Sitting elegantly on Huntington Harbor, this restaurant offers a breathtaking view along with its mouthwatering selection of dry-aged USDA prime steaks. From the ribeye to the porterhouse for two, each steak is expertly cooked and beautifully presented.
Bryant & Cooper Steakhouse
For over three decades, Bryant & Cooper has held its place as one of Long Island’s premier steakhouses. The Roslyn-based restaurant boasts a variety of cuts, each one seared to perfection and served in a sophisticated setting. Don't miss their famous lobster cocktail.
Tellers: An American Chophouse
Housed in a majestic former bank building, Tellers brings a unique twist to the traditional steakhouse. Their broad range of cuts and creative menu, including options like the espresso-rubbed ribeye, offers a modern take on classic steakhouse cuisine.
Insignia Prime Steak & Sushi
Insignia is an absolute gem that combines the best of both worlds – high-grade steaks and fresh sushi. Here, you can start with a sushi appetizer before diving into a juicy, well-aged steak. The modern, stylish ambiance elevates the dining experience.
Blackstone Steakhouse
Blackstone Steakhouse is a Melville-based restaurant that offers a sleek, stylish dining experience. This steakhouse is not just about the steaks; the sides are just as impressive, from creamed spinach to lobster mac and cheese. An extensive wine list adds to the restaurant’s charm.
Frank’s Steaks
If you're looking for an old-school, no-nonsense steakhouse, Frank's Steaks is the place to be. Famous for their marinated Romanian skirt steak, this Rockville Centre eatery also serves a range of other cuts that are equally impressive.
RARE650
RARE650 offers a chic, vibrant setting to enjoy some of Long Island’s best steaks. Alongside traditional cuts, they serve up innovative dishes such as the wagyu meatball starter. Their raw bar and sushi menu add to the variety of flavors available.
Peter Luger
Peter Luger, with a location in Great Neck, is a New York institution renowned for its quality steaks. This Michelin-starred steakhouse has a straightforward menu, with the dry-aged, grilled Porterhouse being the undeniable star. Despite its upscale reputation, the atmosphere is welcomingly unpretentious.
Strip Steak
Situated in the quaint town of Great River, Strip Steak is known for its intimate setting and spectacular steaks. The menu is a blend of traditional steakhouse favorites and innovative dishes. Their eponymous strip steak is a crowd favorite, but don't miss their unique appetizers, like bacon-wrapped dates.
Rothmann’s Steakhouse
A historical icon since 1907, Rothmann’s Steakhouse in East Norwich exudes charm and sophistication. It pairs its delicious steak offerings with a rich history, creating a unique dining experience. Its wide selection of wines perfectly complements the flavorful steaks.
From the waterfront views of Prime to the historic charm of Rothmann’s Steakhouse, Long Island is home to an impressive array of steakhouses, each offering a unique dining experience. Whether you prefer a classic, dry-aged porterhouse or a tender filet mignon, these restaurants offer something for every steak lover. Additionally, many provide an array of appetizing non-steak options and a carefully curated selection of wines and cocktails. Satisfy your carnivorous cravings and embark on a delicious exploration of Long Island's top 10 steakhouses today!